BCGBA SGM: An update
Bowling News
In the absence of anything official coming out of yesterday's Special General Meeting of the BCGBA so far, I offer this independent report from the Vice-Chair of the Federation of Crown Green Bowls. That is Tony Hodgett who attended the meeting on Saturday in Warrington and I published his previously aired hopes on the dispute earlier today. This personal update on the SGM has been published on the Federation's website, dated yesterday, and addressed to David Kay the Chairman of the Federation.
BCGBA Governance Meeting — A personal update
14 November 2026
Tony Hodgetts I Vice Chair, Federation Of Crown Green Bowls
Hi David,
I thought I'd give you a bit of an update following the BCGBA governance meeting on Saturday, which I attended in my capacity as Federation Vice Chair. It lasted around three hours and, to be honest, it was quite an experience. There was plenty of discussion, quite a bit of disagreement and, unfortunately, not a great deal of progress.
The meeting was opened by Lisa Graham from the BDA, Who had been appointed by the Board to act as an independent chair. Her appointment was immediately challenged by the Executive. Alan Stephenson, Chair of Trustees, proposed that Lisa should be removed and replaced by the existing BCGBA President. I felt this was putting the cart before the horse, so I suggested that we should first decide whether Lisa should remain as chair. If she was voted out, we could then consider who should replace her, rather than automatically passing the chair to the President. The meeting voted on whether Lisa should remain and this was carried by a clear majority, so she continued to chair the meeting.
Once the main discussions got underway, things became rather heated. There were numerous references to the Bye-Laws, with both the Board and Executive quoting their interpretations and saying they had Legal advice to support their positions. At times, things became quite personal, which was a shame because the real issues needed addressing. One of the biggest sticking points was the temporary appointment of Michelle Jones, Jim Drain and Dominic Condello to the Board. The Executive made it quite clear that it did not recognise these appointments, questioning both whether Steve Cochrane and Dan Newton had the authority to make them and whether the correct procedures had been followed. My own impression was that the Board seemed more prepared to have an open discussion and listen to what the meeting wanted, whereas the Executive appeared unwilling to give any ground. That is just my personal take on what I witnessed.
Dan Newton's resignation was confirmed, although he is working through his notice period. Steve Cochrane's possible departure in Merch was also mentioned, although Steve did not make that statement himself at the meeting.
There was also an issue that directly affected us as a Federation. Pat Crowther from the Executive questioned why we had two votes when, apparently, British parks only had one. The Board couldn't explain why we had two. I asked about the position with British parks and, having been told they had one vote, I said I was prepared to concede our second vote. That was accepted by the meeting.
Resolution I, which asked Member Associations whether they supported the proposed approach to restoring and strengthening the governance and operations of the BCGBA, also caused considerable disagreement. The Executive's Objection was that it amounted to gerrymandering. Its argument was that whichever way associations voted, the Board would still remain in place: a YES vote would support the proposed approach and leave the Board in place, while a NO vote would mean reverting to the status quo, which would also leave the Board in place. In other words, the Executive felt there was no meaningful choice being offered. There were further contributions, but nothing was resolved and no vote took place.
Eventually, Calvin Jackson, Secretary of Derbyshire, suggested that the Board and Executive should get together, try to sort out their differences and come back with a joint resolution to put before another SGM. That sounds a reasonable suggestion in principle, but I did raise what I thought was a fairly obvious question. If the Executive doesn't recognise Michelle Jones, Jim Drain and Dominic Condello as Board members, and Dan Newton has resigned, who exactly is the Executive going to sit down with to negotiate this joint resolution? I was allowed to put the question, but it went unanswered and the meeting closed shortly afterwards.
I think this needs to be clarified before any meaningful discussions can take place.
So, where does all this leave us? We haven't really moved much further forward in resolving the underlying dispute. We have a suggestion for a way forward, but there are still some pretty fundamental questions to answer before it can happen.
I hope both sides will take Calvin's suggestion seriously and put the interests of the game ahead of their differences. We cannot keep going on like this; the uncertainty is not doing crown green bowls any favours.
I came away with mixed feelings. There is perhaps an opportunity to find a way forward, but it will require some give and take from both sides. One thing I am certain of is that this dispute needs to be brought to an end. Crown green bowls is bigger than any individual, committee or group of officials, and it is the game and its members who should come first. I'll keep everyone updated as things develop.
As always, regards
Tony





Comments